In the spring of each year S&T's design teams head out to various engineering events. Hardly a competition goes by that some school's team doesn't get upset at the judges for some perceived slight.
Interpretation of the rules, "curve balls' thrown at teams just for the (apparent) fun of it, or simple differences of opinion can make the events, uh, interesting.

While we post some photos of the judges at work, we thought we'd pass along an observation or two.

At the steel bridge nationals it became apparent that there is more to event judging than meets the eye. You see, judges don't volunteer for these events purely out of the goodness of their hearts (though many do), to get out of the office for a few days (maybe some do), or to get those cool orange polo shirts (probably none do). The also want ACCESS to their future employees.

They don't necessarily size up individuals, but they DO figure out which teams work together cohesively, because they want students who can contribute immediately in a TEAM environment that is the modern workplace.
For example, we were approached by a judge who owns a Florida firm that designs and builds (duh!) bridges, and he passed on the following:
1. His firm strongly prefers to hire students from the Midwest. In fact, he said (and we aren't making this up) they prefer the third child of a poor Midwest farmer, because:
a. They are used to doing without, so they don't expect much
b. They can get the job done with what little assets are on hand
c. When they grow up there isn't room on the farm 'cause of the older kids, so.....
d. They often head to Missouri S&T where they join a design team and become fabulous engineering students, 'cause they not only know HOW things work, but WHY things work!
What happens next? His engineering firm snaps 'em up because (insert drum roll here....) S&T gals and guys KNOW how to work and contribute from the first day on the job.
When we pressed him for more info, he commented that the big-name New England and Ivy League schools graduate very smart engineers, who, when presented with a real-world problem, don't quite know where to start because that haven't had experience on top design teams like S&T's world-beaters (he did allow that Princeton might be an exception to that rule, but that school is in New Jersey anyway, not New England). He also hinted that some well-known west coast schools whose location suggests that they might have a surfing major, "just don't get it".
In fact, this firm's prez wants to visit the Miner's campus to make presentations about the challenges of designing and building bridges in the real world, as well as to strengthen his firm's connection to S&T's best. Trust us, we'll be talking to this gentleman for some time to come.
Continue reading "The Real Skinny on Judging and Judges" »